Yet, amidst the doubts and skepticism, there is a glimmer of belief within the Tamworth ranks. Manager Andy Peaks has instilled a fighting spirit in his team, reminding them that anything is possible in the magic of the FA Cup.
"We're the underdogs, but that's nothing new to us," Peaks told the local press. "We've proven all season that we can compete with anyone on our day. We're going to give it our all and see what happens."
While a victory over Tottenham might seem like a long shot, Tamworth has shown time and again that they are capable of springing a surprise. In the second round, they stunned League One side Morecambe with a 2-1 victory, proving that they can punch above their weight.
"We'll be playing with nothing to lose," said Tamworth captain Tom Tonks. "We know it's going to be tough, but we're going to go out there and give it our best. Who knows, maybe we can cause an upset."
Whether Tamworth can pull off the miracle remains to be seen. But one thing is for sure: the club and its loyal fans will savor every moment of this David vs. Goliath encounter. The FA Cup has a long history of producing giant-killings, and Tamworth will be hoping to add their name to the list of underdogs who have triumphed against all odds.
So, as the two teams prepare to face off on that historic evening, the question lingers: will Tamworth become a sacrificial lamb to Tottenham's Premier League might, or will they emerge as the conquering heroes?